1998 Dry Onion Cultivar Trials

W.B. Evans. Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center

Muck Crops Branch, Willard, OH 44890

The 1998 long day onion trial consisted of four plots each of 10 entries grown at the O.A.R.D.C. Muck Crops Branch in Willard, OH and one plot each of 33 observational entries. Each plot contained 3 rows, 20 ft. long and 19 in. apart. Plots were spring plowed and fertilized with 700 lb. 16-8-26. Plots were sown April 29 at approximately 12 seeds/ft. A cover crop of wheat (1 bu./acre) was broadcast after the onions were sown. An in-furrow insecticide was applied at planting and standard pest management practices were used during the season. Calcium nitrate (53 lb. N/acre) was broadcast on June 23. Manganese (4 lb./acre) was sprayed on the foliage July 28. The plots were subject to four flooding rains during production, each resulting in standing water for at least 12 hours. A fast developing outbreak of foliar disease followed a flooding rain in late July, likely contributing to our disappointing yields. Fungicide treatments continued and all but one cultivar continued to grow toward the time of bulbing. Thrips were well controlled. Onion maggot damage was negligible. Weed pressure was also well managed. Overhead irrigation was used in May and between heavy rains when needed.

The crop was harvested the week of September 14, air cured, and stored for 8 weeks. Bulbs were then graded, weighed, and counted. Few large bulbs (>3.5 inches) were produced by any cultivar. These were not separated from the 2-3.5 inch onions during grading. A ten bulb sample of bulbs larger than 2 inches was retained and rated qualitatively for color, shape, and scale retention.

The best performing entries in the replicated trial tended to be those already grown locally including Burgos and Daytona (Table 1). Frontier yielded well but did not hold its scales well during curing. Athos and Corona may have sized better had the season been more suited to longer season entries. Other replicated entries appeared to have lower yield potential or other quality faults. Mars, the only red entry in the replicated trial, performed worse than both red entries in the observational trial.


 

Table 1. Dry onion cultivar characteristics at grading of replicated plots.

 

Cultivar

 

Source1

Yield

<2 in.

(lb./plot)

Yield

>2 in.

(lb./plot)

Yield soft /sprouted

(lb./plot)

Yield

total

(lb./plot)

Mean weight

>2 in. bulbs

(oz.)




Outer scale retention2





Bulb shape3





Bulb color4

Burgos

VL

20.2

20.2

1.8

42.2

2.91

F/G

FG

MBRZ

Daytona

BZ

22.1

19.4

2.5

43.9

2.87

G

TG

M/DBRW

Frontier

AT

16.4

17.2

2.5

36.1

2.66

P/F

FG

LBRW

Corona

BZ

28.1

12.7

4.6

45.3

2.73

P/F

TG

LBRZ

Hoopla

RC/SI

27.4

9.9

7.5

44.8

2.92

P/F

G

L/MBRZ

Athos

VL

32.1

8.9

1.9

42.8

2.73

P/F

T

L/MBRW

Uni-Globe 118

PS

18.8

8.5

8.7

36.0

2.98

F/G

PG

M/DBRW

Uni-Globe 108

PS

17.7

7.6

5.3

30.7

2.74

F

FG

MBRW

Cisco

BZ

24.4

6.0

2.3

32.7

2.63

P

FG

LBRZ

Mars

PS

15.7

3.5

3.9

23.1

2.72

F

P

VRD

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

LSD0.05

 

9.3

7.2

2.9

12.4

0.26

 

 

 

1 Source ocdes: AT=American Takii; BZ=Bejo Zaden; PS=Peto Seeds; RC=Rio Colorado; SI=Siegers; VL=Vilmorin;

2Scale retention codes: P-poor; F-fair; G-good; n.d.-not determined.

3Bulb shape codes: F-flat; G-globe; T-tall; H-high: P pointed n.d.-not determined.

4Bulb color codes: L-light; M-medium; D-dark; BRW-brown; BRZ-bronze; WHT-white; VRD-violet red; PRD-purple red; n.d.-not determined.

  

The best performing yellow onions in the observational trial were Legend, Altisimo, Festival and Rio Lobo (Table 2). Legend did not size as well as some others but might have needed a little better weather to size properly. Rio Lobo, Festival and Altisimo produced larger marketable bulbs but also might have done better had the season allowed for greater sizing. Altisimo did not retain its scales well during curing. Santos yielded well and had the largest bulb size in the trial, but had many rotten and sprouted bulbs after curing. Uni-Globe 100 might also have benefited from better weather. Tamara produced large bulbs but had a small number of onions harvested, indicating a stand problem. Ailisa Craig Exhibition appeared to have many sweet onion characteristics including the tendency to rot during curing.

Redwing was the best performing red cultivar across both trials. Mercury had more rotten onions after curing. Gladstone, a white, might have been acceptable in a better season.


 

Table 2. Dry onion cultivar characteristics at grading of observational plots.

 

Cultivar

 

Source1

Yield

<2 in.

(lb./plot)

Yield

>2 in.

(lb./plot)

Yield soft /sprouted

(lb./plot)

Yield

total

(lb./plot)

Mean weight

>2 in. bulbs

(oz)

Outer scale retention2

Bulb

shape3

Bulb

color4

Santos

VL

9.7

48.0

6.6

64.3

4.1

F

FG

LBRW

Legend

BZ

28.2

38.8

4.2

71.1

2.5

F/G

TG

LBRW

Altisimo

BZ

17.0

25.4

3.1

45.4

3.3

P/F

TG

MBRZ

Festival

BZ

21.1

24.7

2.6

48.3

3.2

F/G

T

MBRZ

Redwing

BZ

17.8

23.8

5.5

47.0

3.1

F/G

FG

PRD

Tamara

BZ

8.0

22.6

2.8

33.4

3.9

F/G

T

MBRZ

Rio Lobo

RC/SI

17.7

19.9

3.1

40.6

2.9

P/F

PG

LBRW

RCS 7120

RC/SI

8.7

19.6

6.2

34.4

3.3

F

FG/G

L/MBRW

Uni-Globe 100

PS

20.4

16.0

6.8

43.1

2.9

P/F

TG

L/MBRZ

Carnival

BZ

21.4

13.5

4.1

39.0

3.0

G

TG

M/DBRW

RCS 7144

RC/SI

18.6

13.4

1.3

33.3

2.8

F/G

FG

MBRW

Chateau

AS

16.8

12.3

2.0

31.1

2.8

G

HG

M/DBRW

Santana

BZ

28.6

11.7

0.0

40.3

2.7

G

FG

L/MBRW

1022

DP/SI

14.1

11.2

1.4

26.6

3.1

F

PG

L/MBRW

Arsenal

AS

15.2

11.2

1.8

28.2

2.8

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

Pathfinder

RC/SI

15.7

10.5

3.2

29.4

3.3

F/G

FG

MBRZ

Lorenzos

VL

20.4

10.0

2.9

33.2

2.6

F/G

FG

M/DBRW

Mercury

PS

17.5

9.4

10.6

37.5

2.9

G

PG

VRD

1023

DP/SI

16.5

7.6

4.8

28.8

2.8

P/F

FG

L/MBRZ

Fleetwood

BZ

13.5

7.1

2.6

23.2

2.8

G/E

P

DBRW

Eagle

RC/SI

23.4

6.4

0.8

30.6

2.6

P/F

PG

MBRW

1059

DP/SI

13.8

5.7

1.4

20.9

3.1

F

FG

LBRW

Flagship

AS

19.4

5.4

1.7

26.5

2.5

G

HG

M/DBRW

Gladstone

BZ

28.8

5.3

0.6

34.7

2.3

P/F

P

WHT

1054

DP/SI

19.4

4.2

2.0

25.6

2.8

P/F

FG

MBRW

Hamlet

AS

19.6

4.1

0.7

24.4

2.5

G

HG

DBRW

Ailisa Craig Exhibition

JS

16.4

3.7

18.0

38.0

2.9

P

P

BRW

Hercules

RC/SI

12.5

2.8

7.2

22.5

2.8

F

G

L/MBRW

Quantum

PS

18.5

2.4

1.6

22.5

2.7

P/F

FG

L/MBRW

VL-224

VL

23.1

2.3

0.0

25.4

2.8

P/F

FG/G

MBRZ

Cavalier

AS

19.2

2.1

0.4

21.7

2.6

G

PG

MBRZ

1060

DP/SI

1.8

1.5

1.2

4.4

3.3

G

TG

M/DBRZ

Mission Star

HM

1.6

0.0

0.0

1.6

0

.

.

WHT

1Source codes: AS=Asgrow; BZ=Bejo Zaden; DP=D. Palmer; HM=Harris Moran; JS=Johnny’s; PS=Peto Seeds; RC=Rio Colorado; SI=Siegers; VL=Vilmorin

2Scale retention codes: P-poor; F-fair; G-good; n.d.-not determined.

3Bulb shape codes: F-flat; G-globe; T-tall; H-high: P pointed n.d.-not determined.

4Bulb color codes: L-light; M-medium; D-dark; BRW-brown; BRZ-bronze; WHT-white; VRD-violet red; PRD-purple red; n.d.-not determined..